Bitcoin’s Resilience: Analyzing the Impact of Regulatory News on the Crypto Market

The cryptocurrency market recently experienced events that were previously expected to present a severe negative price impact, and yet, Bitcoin (BTC) trades near $37,000 on Nov. 22, which is essentially flat from three days prior. Such performance was utterly unexpected given the relevance of Binance’s plea deal on Nov. 21 with the United States Authorities for violating laws involving money laundering and terror financing.

Bearish news has had limited impact on Bitcoin price

One might argue that entities have been manipulating Bitcoin’s price to avoid contagion, possibly involving the issuing of unbacked stablecoins–especially those with direct ties to the exchanges suffering from the regulatory pressure. Thus, to identify whether investors became highly risk-averse one should analyze Bitcoin derivatives instead of focusing solely on the current price levels.

The U.S. government filed indictments against Binance and Changpeng “CZ” Zhao in Washington state on Nov. 14, but the documents were unsealed on Nov. 21. After admitting the offenses, CZ stepped away from Binance management as part of the deal. Penalties totaled over $4 billion, including fines imposed on CZ personally. The news triggered a mere $50 million in BTC leverage long futures contracts after Bitcoin’s price momentarily traded down to $35,600.

It is worth noting that on Nov. 20 the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) sued Kraken exchange, alleging it commingled customer funds and failed to register with the regulator as a securities broker, dealer and clearing agency. Additionally, the complaint claimed Kraken paid for operational expenses directly from accounts containing customer assets. However, Kraken said the SEC’s commingling accusations were previously earned fees, so essentially their proprietary assets.

Another potentially disastrous tidbit of news came from Mt. Gox, a now-defunct Bitcoin exchange that lost 850,000 BTC to a hack in 2014. Nobuaki Kobayashi, the Mt. Gox trustee announced on Nov. 21 the redemption of $47 million in trust assets and reportedly planned to start the first cash repayments to creditors in 2023. Even though there was no information regarding the sale of Bitcoin assets, investors speculated that this final milestone is closer than ever.

One will find posts on social networks from experienced traders and analysts that anticipated a crypto market crash in case Binance were to be indicted by the DoJ. Some examples are listed below, and it is safe to say such a theory was almost a consensus among investors.

“ETF denied, slow bleed is most likely, with a switch to hard crash if DOJ charges are unsealed soon against Binance.” – Parrot Capital

“I do not believe in coincidences. The Universe is rarely so lazy. Expecting ETFs to be rejected and DoJ to drop the hammer on Binance crushing bulls dreams for 2023.” – McKenna

Notice how McKenna predicted that Binance would be indicted by the DoJ and further added that the ongoing Bitcoin spot exchange-traded (ETF) fund applications will be denied by the SEC. But, as counterintuitive as it might sound, Binance going fully compliant increases the odds of the spot ETF approval. This is because it greatly weakens the SEC’s main argument for previous denials, namely the excessive volume market share on unregulated exchanges.

Nothing concrete came out from the spot Bitcoin ETF in regards to recent regulatory actions, but the amends to multiple proposals is a hint of a healthy discussion with the SEC.

Bitcoin derivatives display resilience

To confirm if the Bitcoin price resilience aligns with professional investors’ risk assessment, one should analyze BTC futures and options metrics. For instance, traders could have rushed to hedge their positions, which doesn’t pressure the spot markets, but vastly impacts BTC futures premium and options pricing.

The price of Bitcoin monthly futures contracts tend to differ from regular spot exchanges since participants demand more money to delay the settlement. That’s not exclusive to cryptocurrencies, and in a neutral market it should stand near an annualized 5% rate.

Notice how Bitcoin futures currently holds an 8% premium, which is an indication of excessive demand for leverage longs, but far from excessive. This level is lower than the 11.5% seen in mid November, but is quite positive given the recent regulatory newsflow.

To confirm if Bitcoin derivatives did not experience a huge inflow of hedge operations, one needs to analyze BTC option markets as well. The 25% delta skew is a telling sign when arbitrage desks and market makers overcharge for upside or downside protection.

As displayed above, the options 25% delta skew indicates optimism for the past 4 weeks as the put (sell) options have been trading at a discount when compared with similar call (buy) options. More importantly, the recent news flow did not change professional traders’ appetite for hedging strategies.

Overall, there’s no doubt that the impact of regulatory actions and the potential sell pressure from Mt Gox caught the market in a great mood given the derivatives indicators. Additionally, the liquidation of $70 million leverage BTC longs reduced the pressure from future negative price oscillations, meaning even if price revisits $35,000, there’s no indication of excessive optimism.

Since the final round of ETF decisions is scheduled for January and February, there’s little incentive for Bitcoin bears to pressure the market while negative news had zero impact. Ultimately, the path to $40,000 becomes more certain.

This article does not contain investment advice or recommendations. Every investment and trading move involves risk, and readers should conduct their own research when making a decision.