Artificial Intelligence Guidelines for Judges and Magistrates in the UK

Senior judges in the United Kingdom have published extensive advice on the proper use of artificial intelligence (AI) for judges and magistrates in England and Wales. This is a major step for the legal system in the United Kingdom. When it comes to integrating artificial intelligence technology inside the legal framework while simultaneously addressing possible hazards and ethical issues, this endeavor represents a pioneering effort.

A cross-jurisdictional judicial body is responsible for initiating the guidelines, which provides courts in England and Wales with instructions on how to make acceptable use of generative artificial intelligence systems like OpenAI’s ChatGPT. While it does not specifically restrict the use of these systems for performing legal research or legal analysis, it does allow their use for the performance of fundamental labor activities. Additionally, the advice provides judges with an alert that informs them to the signals that legal arguments may have been generated by an artificial intelligence chatbot. These signs include references to cases that are unknown or false, as well as different interpretations of the same legal problem.

The instruction provided by the court places an emphasis on the need for those holding judicial office to be aware of the possible hazards that are linked with public versions of AI technologies. It is strongly recommended that judges refrain from putting any kinds of private or secret information into these systems. Moreover, the guideline is meant to be the first step in a series of support measures that will be implemented for the judicial system in their dealings with artificial intelligence. It is also intended to create a frequently asked questions paper in order to better reinforce the recommendations.

It was brought to the attention of Geoffrey Vos, who is the Head of Civil Justice in England and Wales, that the guideline is the very first of its sort in the jurisdiction. Despite the fact that Vos emphasized the benefits that artificial intelligence presents for the judicial system, he also emphasized how important it is for judges to have a grasp of both the capabilities and limits of AI. He placed a strong emphasis on the capacity of the judicial system to differentiate between actual legal arguments and those that were prepared using artificial intelligence, including the possibility of utilizing deepfakes as evidence.

Image source: Shutterstock